· 9 min read

Reg A Tier 1 vs Tier 2: Limits, State Review, Audits and Marketing

Reg A+ Tier 1 vs Tier 2 compared: offering limits, the 10% investor rule, state review, audits, ongoing reports and testing-the-waters marketing rules.

Head of Marketing & Growth
Summarize with AI
Reg A Tier 1 vs Tier 2: Limits, State Review, Audits and Marketing

Reg A+ Tier 1 lets a company raise up to $20 million in 12 months with unaudited financials, but the offering must be registered or qualified in every state where it is sold. Tier 2 raises the limit to $75 million and removes state registration, but it requires audited financials, caps most non-accredited investors at 10% of income or net worth, and brings annual, semiannual and current reporting. For most raises marketed online across several states, Tier 2 is the practical choice; Tier 1 fits small, local raises in one or a few states.

Offering limits: what "up to $75 million" actually means

Regulation A caps are measured over any rolling 12-month period, not per offering. At the time of writing, the SEC's rules set:

  • Tier 1: up to $20 million, of which no more than $6 million can come from affiliated selling securityholders (founders, officers or large holders selling their own shares).
  • Tier 2: up to $75 million, of which no more than $22.5 million can come from affiliated selling securityholders.
  • First offering rule: in an issuer's first Reg A offering and any offering in the following 12 months, sales by all selling securityholders together are limited to 30% of the aggregate offering price.

If you plan to raise in stages, model the rolling window early: a second round eleven months after the first still counts against the same limit.

Not every company qualifies. Reg A is limited to issuers organized and headquartered in the US or Canada and excludes investment companies, blank-check companies, issuers of fractional oil and gas interests, asset-backed securities, companies that missed required Reg A reports in the prior two years, and issuers with disqualified "bad actors."

Who can invest: the Tier 2 10% rule and when it falls away

Tier 1 has no federal per-investor limit. Any person can invest any amount, subject to whatever conditions the states impose during their review.

Tier 2 adds an investment limit for non-accredited investors. A non-accredited individual can buy no more than 10% of the greater of annual income or net worth. For a non-accredited entity, the limit is 10% of the greater of annual revenue or net assets for the most recently completed fiscal year. Accredited investors have no limit.

Two practical points matter here:

  • The limit does not apply to securities that will be listed on a national securities exchange upon qualification. Issuers combining Reg A+ with an exchange listing avoid the cap entirely.
  • Issuers may rely on the investor's own representation of compliance with the limit, unless they know it is untrue. In practice the representation and the accreditation question sit inside the subscription flow, so the checkout form is part of compliance, not just design.

State review: Tier 1 registration vs Tier 2 preemption

This is the difference that decides most tier choices. A Tier 1 offering must be registered or qualified in each state where securities are offered or sold. That means separate state reviews, state comments, and in some states merit review of the deal terms themselves. Many states participate in a coordinated review program to reduce duplication, but the process still adds time and legal cost on top of the SEC review.

Tier 2 securities are treated as "covered securities," so states cannot require registration or qualification. They can still require notice filings and fees, and they keep full antifraud authority. A state can halt sales in its territory if the notice filing is skipped, so preemption is not the same as ignoring the states.

For a raise marketed online to a national audience, Tier 1 state registration is usually impractical: every state where your ads or emails reach a buyer becomes a filing.

Audited financials and the qualification process

Tier 1 issuers may file unaudited financial statements unless audited statements already exist for another purpose. Tier 2 requires financial statements audited under either AICPA (US GAAS) or PCAOB standards. Financial statements also go stale after a set period, so the audit calendar should drive the launch date, not the other way around.

Both tiers go through the same SEC process. The offering statement is filed on Form 1-A through EDGAR and includes the offering circular, financials and exhibits. SEC staff in the Division of Corporation Finance review it and usually send a comment letter. The issuer answers with an amended filing, and the cycle repeats until the staff has no further comments and a notice of qualification is issued. No securities can be sold before qualification.

First-time issuers can submit a draft offering statement for non-public review. The draft must be substantially complete, and the draft, amendments and staff correspondence must be filed publicly on EDGAR at least 21 calendar days before qualification.

The SEC does not publish a standard timeline. In practice the duration depends on how complete the first filing is, how many comment rounds follow, and how quickly counsel and auditors respond. A clean Tier 2 filing with a finished audit moves meaningfully faster than one where the audit is still in progress. Tier 1 adds state reviews that can run in parallel with the SEC process but often finish later.

Ongoing reporting after a Tier 2 raise

Tier 1 issuers file only an exit report on Form 1-Z within 30 calendar days after the offering ends. Tier 2 issuers take on continuing obligations:

  • Form 1-K: annual report with audited financials, due within 120 calendar days after fiscal year end.
  • Form 1-SA: semiannual report, due within 90 calendar days after the end of the first half of the fiscal year.
  • Form 1-U: current report within four business days of specified events, such as a change in control, bankruptcy, or unregistered sales of 10% or more of outstanding equity.

Missing these reports has consequences beyond a warning: an issuer that failed to file required Reg A reports in the two years before a new offering statement cannot use Regulation A again. Budget for a recurring audit and for someone who owns the reporting calendar, not only for the launch.

Testing the waters: what marketing materials must include

Rule 255 lets issuers in both tiers "test the waters": communicate orally or in writing to gauge interest before and after filing Form 1-A. You can run a reservation page, send emails and publish ads before qualification, but you cannot accept money or binding commitments.

Every written solicitation must state that:

  • no money or other consideration is being solicited, and if sent in response, it will not be accepted;
  • no offer to buy can be accepted and no part of the purchase price can be received until the offering statement is qualified, and any such offer may be withdrawn or revoked without obligation before acceptance;
  • a person's indication of interest involves no obligation or commitment of any kind;
  • once the offering statement is publicly filed, where the most recent preliminary offering circular can be obtained, for example through a link or URL.

Written test-the-waters materials are filed as exhibits to the offering statement, and they stay subject to antifraud rules. If materials are revised after an earlier version went out, the revised version must be redistributed in a substantially similar manner. That makes version control of the landing page and ad creatives a compliance task.

Tier 1 vs Tier 2 at a glance

RuleTier 1Tier 2
12-month maximum$20 million$75 million
Affiliate selling holdersUp to $6 millionUp to $22.5 million
Non-accredited limitNone federally10% of income or net worth; none if exchange-listed
State reviewRegister in each statePreempted; notice filings and fees
Financial statementsUnaudited allowedAudited (AICPA or PCAOB)
SEC qualificationForm 1-A, comment lettersForm 1-A, comment letters
Ongoing reportingExit report on Form 1-ZForms 1-K, 1-SA, 1-U
Testing the watersAllowed with legendsAllowed with legends

What this means for the investor website and campaign

The tier changes what the site has to do. A common mistake we see is a campaign site designed like a product launch, with compliance text added at the end. For a Reg A+ raise the structure should start from the rules:

  • Legends in the template. Rule 255 statements belong in the page layout, form confirmations, emails and ad landing pages, so no variant ships without them.
  • Offering circular links. After public filing, every page that discusses the offer should link to the current preliminary or final offering circular on EDGAR, and the link should be updated with each amendment.
  • Reservation vs investment states. Before qualification, the form collects non-binding indications of interest only. After qualification, it switches to the subscription flow with the 10% limit representation for Tier 2.
  • Counsel review of ads. Every claim about returns, growth or valuation, plus each ad creative and email, should pass securities counsel before publication. Keep an archive of what ran and when, because filed materials must match.
  • Broker-dealer involvement. If anyone receives transaction-based compensation for selling the securities, that party generally must be a registered broker-dealer, and its communications follow FINRA rules. Platforms that run the investment flow often add their own review step, so plan for two reviewers.
  • Reporting after the raise. Tier 2 issuers need a place for Form 1-K, 1-SA and 1-U links and investor updates, so an investor relations section is easier to plan from day one.

Our Reg A+ websites start from $6,000 and take 3 to 6 weeks, with legends, circular links and reservation-to-subscription states built into the templates. Larger multi-page investor websites start from $10,000, and ongoing investor relations support starts from $6,000. The story that the site, ads and investor calls repeat is usually worked out first in the pitch deck.

How to choose: a practical decision rule

  • Choose Tier 2 if you plan to market online across several states, need more than $20 million, or want a path to an exchange listing. The audit and ongoing reports are the price of avoiding state-by-state registration.
  • Consider Tier 1 only if the raise is small, sold in one or a few states where you already have an investor base, and the company cannot yet support a recurring audit.
  • Look beyond Reg A if all your investors are accredited or the amount fits a crowdfunding round; the qualification process may cost more than it returns.

Whatever the tier, settle three things before design starts: the audit date, who signs off on marketing copy, and whether a broker-dealer or platform runs the investment flow. Those decisions shape the site more than the visual direction does.

This article is general information, not legal or investment advice. Offering compliance stays with your securities counsel and funding portal.

FAQ

Questions & answers

Contact us

At the time of writing, Tier 2 allows up to $75 million in any 12-month period, including no more than $22.5 million from affiliated selling securityholders. Tier 1 allows up to $20 million, with up to $6 million from affiliates. In a first Reg A offering, all selling securityholders together are limited to 30% of the offering.

Yes. Rule 255 allows solicitations of interest before and after the offering statement is filed, in both tiers. You cannot accept money or binding commitments until the SEC qualifies the offering, and written materials must carry the required statements and be filed as exhibits.

Tier 2 offerings do not need state registration or qualification. States can still require notice filings and fees and can enforce antifraud rules, so counsel usually prepares notice filings for every state where investors are located.

No. The Tier 2 limit applies only to non-accredited investors, and it does not apply at all when the securities will be listed on a national securities exchange upon qualification. Tier 1 has no federal per-investor limit.

An annual report on Form 1-K within 120 days of fiscal year end, a semiannual report on Form 1-SA within 90 days after the first half, and current reports on Form 1-U within four business days of specified events. Missing them can block future Reg A offerings.

10+ years in business, 100+ projects, clients in 9+ countries